How Russia-Ukraine Tensions Are Shaping Global Aviation

Airport sign: "All Flights Canceled", passengers walking.

The ongoing Russia-Ukraine conflict has wreaked havoc on the global airline industry, forcing European carriers to navigate complex new realities while Chinese airlines seize opportunities.

At a Glance

European airlines are facing increased operational costs due to sanctions that prevent them from using Russian airspace.
Chinese airlines benefit from unrestricted access, providing shorter, less expensive routes to Europe.
European CEOs propose policy changes to level the competitive landscape.
Chinese carriers have significantly expanded their market share in Europe.

The Challenge for European Carriers

European airlines have been barred from Russian airspace due to sanctions imposed in response to the conflict in Ukraine. This restriction has forced these airlines to adopt longer, more expensive routes, particularly impacting their service to Asia. In contrast, Chinese airlines continue to fly via Russian airspace, offering faster and more cost-effective routes.

European carriers, including Lufthansa, have suggested measures such as enforcing a blanket ban on flights utilizing Russian airspace. Carsten Spohr, CEO of Lufthansa, believes that reducing the advantage of Chinese carriers is critical to restoring fair competition. Spohr stated, “We are not allowed to cross Russia but Chinese carriers are. If you want a level playing field, we need to ensure any airline landing in Europe avoids Russian airspace.”

The European Union has proposed new trade restrictions for the first time on three Chinese firms accused of supporting Russia’s war efforts in Ukraine https://t.co/YAPwsc9UNC

— Bloomberg Markets (@markets) February 12, 2024

Impact of Chinese Airlines’ Strategies

Chinese airlines have expanded their presence in Europe by increasing the number of flights and routes. This strategic move has allowed them to dominate the market, now holding a 77% share of the traffic between China and Europe, an increase from 50% pre-pandemic. Key players, such as Air China and China Southern, have notably expanded, surpassing their pre-2019 operational levels.

“It is a competitive disadvantage for the European carriers. That’s clear,” said Aletta von Massenbach, acknowledging the struggles faced by European airlines.

European airlines, such as British Airways, Lufthansa, and LOT, have suspended numerous Asian routes as a result of heightened costs due to increased distances and higher fuel consumption. This not only impacts profitability but also diminishes their market competitiveness. Furthermore, European airlines describe themselves as “victims of political decisions” with little hope for compensation or policy shifts. Willie Walsh noted, “You could make a case that the airlines that have been impacted by the political decision should be compensated. But I doubt there’s much appetite in the Commission or the European countries to do that.”

Tweets by SecBlinken

Potential Remedies and Future Outlook

The European Commission has proposed a study to analyze competition on international routes, but the industry remains skeptical about any significant policy changes. There’s speculative discussion on Europe implementing measures such as potential pricing strategies to deter unfair competition.

“I don’t expect anything to come out of this,” Willie Walsh mentioned regarding proposed EU actions.

Some industry leaders, like KLM CEO Marjan Rintel, suggest exploring different strategies to counterbalance the current disadvantages European airlines face. “Europe can at least look at how we can prevent that unfair playing field by pricing it or looking at it in a different way.”