Governor Healey Faces Backlash Amid Rising Tensions in Migrant Shelters

Tents and belongings set up along sidewalk.

Massachusetts Republicans criticize Governor Maura Healey as violence in state-funded migrant shelters continues to rise, sparking a tense debate about the state’s immigration policies.

At a Glance

The Massachusetts Executive Office of Housing and Livable Communities documented 316 ‘serious incident’ reports since 2022.
Governor Healey ordered inspections of all state-run emergency shelters amid escalating safety concerns.
Critics, including Republican lawmakers, argue the administration’s response is belated and insufficient.
Serious offenses, such as drug trafficking and assaults, reported in Massachusetts shelters.

Governor Healey’s Administration Under Fire

The Massachusetts Republican Party has directed sharp criticism toward Governor Maura Healey’s handling of violence in migrant shelters. Documents obtained via the Freedom of Information Act reveal unsettling incidents, including physical and sexual assaults. Republicans point to lax oversight as the root cause. The arrest of Leonardo Andujar Sanchez in a Revere shelter last December, found with firearms and fentanyl, marked a turning point in their campaign for stricter policies.

Governor Healey ordered inspections of state shelters after Sanchez’s arrest, as pressure mounted. These inspections, focused on identifying criminal activity, are conducted by on-site shelter staff. Governor Healey, meanwhile, emphasized migrants’ compliance with rules and productive contributions. However, critics infer that ongoing criminal incidents signal a failure to establish a safe environment.

Critics Demand Accountability

Jessica Vaughan, a vocal critic, argued, “This is very disturbing. This is a huge number of incidents.” The controversy has sparked a wider debate over Massachusetts’ Right-to-Shelter law, which critics claim acts as an enticement for migrants and adds a burden to the state’s resources. GOP Chair Amy Carnevale described the current situation as a “humanitarian crisis,” clarifying that state measures are inadequate to meet the challenges faced.

“This is a huge failure, and it’s happening with massive amounts of taxpayer money. The state is clearly failing to provide a safe environment for these migrants,” said Vaughan.

In addition to Sanchez, another incident involving Cory Bernard Alvarez, a Haitian national arrested for child rape in a Rockland shelter, highlighted systemic issues within the program. Alvarez was released on bond but re-arrested, adding to public outrage. Concerns over drug and weaponry possession within shelters prompted calls for increased policing and greater transparency.

Tweets by MassGovernor

Federal Inaction and Local Frustration

Republican state legislator Peter Durant is among those urging transparency regarding inspection findings. Governor Healey has criticized federal immigration policies, seeking a border security bill to prevent criminal entries. Nevertheless, state Republicans contend these federal shortcomings emphasize the urgent need for state-level reforms to address the problematic shelter system effectively.

“This further underscores our broken federal immigration system and the urgent need for Congress and the White House to act on a border security bill to prevent criminals from entering our communities,” said Healey said.

Massachusetts continues to face challenges in its immigration system, made more complex by court limitations following the 2017 Lunn ruling, which restricts holding individuals solely based on federal detainers. This legal framework complicates state efforts to manage the migrant shelter crisis while maintaining public safety.